What to Say When a Buyer Says "This Seems Overpriced" at an Open House
By ScriptAI Coach ·
It happens quickly. Someone walks through the door, looks around, and says, "This seems overpriced." If you host open houses, you will hear a version of that line more than once.
The instinct is to defend the list price: recent comps, upgrades, the busy market, the seller's reasons. That instinct usually makes the conversation tighter, not better. A price comment is often a first impression, a comparison to another house, or a polite way of saying "this is above what I want to spend." It is not automatically a verdict.
The wording below is example language you can adapt at an open house. It is not a quote from a real visitor.
Treat it as a question, not a debate
You do not need to agree that the home is overpriced, and you do not need to prove that it isn't. You need to understand what "overpriced" means to this person.
A calm first reply might be:
I hear that a lot when buyers are comparing quickly. What feels high about it to you?
That question does two things. It takes the heat out of the comment, and it asks for a specific comparison. Some visitors mean the price per square foot. Some mean the condition. Some mean their budget. Some mean a house they saw last weekend. You will not know unless you ask.
If you start with a defense, the visitor has to either back down or double down. Neither is a useful conversation. If you get curious, they can tell you whether this is a firm "no" or a number that might still work.
Get specific about the comparison
Once they answer, follow the thread. A good second question separates "I don't like the house" from "the number is the problem."
You might ask:
Are you comparing it against other homes you've seen, or against what you'd personally want to stay within?
If they say both, ask where this one misses financially. Keep your tone even. You are not cross-examining them in the kitchen. You are helping them put words to a reaction.
Listen for phrases like "a little above what I'd want to spend" or "unless there was some flexibility." Those are different from "this house isn't worth it at any number." The first leaves room for a conversation about budget, approval, and whether the home would stay on their list if the price felt more workable.
You can reflect that back without pushing:
So if the number felt more negotiable, you'd be more interested than your first comment makes it sound.
Then pause. Let them agree, disagree, or qualify it. "Maybe" is still more information than you had when they walked in.
Find out whether the interest is real
A price comment can come from a serious, already-approved buyer or from someone who is only browsing. The next questions should be ordinary discovery, not a close.
Ask whether they are already in a position to buy if the right opportunity came up. Ask what range they are most comfortable with. If they say they are approved and looking slightly below this list price, you now know something useful: they may not dislike the house. The price has to make sense against their budget.
A simple check-in is:
If this one had room to negotiate, would it stay on your list?
If the answer is yes, or even "probably," you have moved from a public criticism to a private interest. That is the point at which you can offer a next step that fits the moment: a follow-up after the open house, a look at comparable sales, or a conversation about what they would need to see to make an offer they feel good about.
You can also ask what they still like about the house despite the price. That question is easy to skip when you are focused on the objection, and it tells you whether there is anything to follow up on later.
Example wording for the moment
Here is a short example of how the exchange can sound. Adjust the details to the home and the visitor.
Visitor: "This seems overpriced."
You: "I hear that a lot when buyers are comparing quickly. What feels high about it to you?"
Visitor: "The price compared with what you actually get."
You: "Makes sense. Are you comparing it against other homes you've seen, or against what you'd personally want to stay within?"
From there, stay with their answer. If they are already approved and slightly under this price, say so plainly: the issue may not be that they dislike the property, it is that the number has to fit. Then ask whether the home would stay on their list if the price felt more negotiable.
Keep your voice lower than the comment. Open houses are public. A visitor who feels corrected in a hallway is unlikely to tell you anything else.
What a stronger conversation can uncover
In a ScriptAI Coach example session for the Open House — Price Critic scenario, the prospect opens with "This seems overpriced." The agent does not argue the list price. Instead, the agent asks what feels high, whether the comparison is to other homes or to a personal budget, and where the home misses financially. The prospect is already approved, wants to stay slightly lower, and says the home would probably stay on their list if there were room to negotiate.
The example is evaluated out of 40 points, including opening, discovery, objection handling, and professional communication. The review of that session noted that the agent moved the conversation from criticism into real buying interest, and still could have asked about the prospect's timeline and which features still made the home attractive.
Those two follow-ups are worth building into your own habit. A visitor who is approved and price-sensitive is a different follow-up than a visitor who is just forming an opinion about the neighborhood. And if they like the layout, the yard, or the location, you have something to work with besides the number.
Practice the open-house price objection
This is a hard conversation to invent on the spot, especially with other people in the room. If you want to rehearse it, you can try the Open House — Price Critic scenario from ScriptAI Coach. It is a live role-play with coaching and a 40-point evaluation at the end. Starting the scenario may require a compatible ChatGPT plan.
When someone says the price feels high, get curious about the comparison. The argument can wait. The question usually cannot.